July 23, 2004

A Panda Walks Into a Bar Redux

My Google ranking for the phrase "A Panda Walks Into a Bar" has fallen from #1 to #12. So, in a misguided attempt to boost my totally worthless placement, I bring you links to two articles related to Eats, Shoots and Leaves:

"You pour thing, if you don't see the point of spelling correctly" by Lynne Truss:

It seems to me that people just resent having to learn things. "How do you explain to an eight-year-old that the word 'yacht' has all these strange letters in it?" a chap once asked me, on the Jeremy Vine Show. This seemed an unanswerable question at the time. It was only afterwards that I worked out my objection to it. Why should the comprehension level of an eight-year-old be our standard for anything?

"For Want of a Comma, the Meaning Was Lost" by Jef Raskin, writing an open letter to Lynne Truss:

And when you say that "you can't write comments in the margin of your screen to be discovered by another reader fifty years down the line," I imagine that you perhaps have not seen threaded discussions and "Wikis". Not only can I add marginal notes, but because of the bidirectional nature of the Web, a comment can become incorporated as part of the material that all subsequent readers see, not just the chance reader of my copy. For example, one comment I made on the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (http://plato.stanford.edu) became incorporated into the work (with due credit). My marginal comments on my paper copy of the OED (Oxford English Dictionary), however, are unlikely to become memorialized so accessibly.